Beyond Suffrage and the Right to Vote by Nicole Thomas

Beyond Suffrage and the Right to Vote

sbaIn the month of March, our nation celebrates Women’s History Month and organizations throughout the country bring together lectures, events, and exhibits to honor the achievements of Women from the past. In Philadelphia, there were many different events being held throughout the city to celebrate Women’s History Month. The event I chose to attend was held at the National Constitution Center. I thought it would be interesting to view their advertised exhibit about Women’s roles in the Constitution. I went with pretty high expectations, as I thought a place as well known as the National Constitution Center would have a great Women’s exhibit, but unfortunately, my enthusiasm for this event went from high to low very quickly.

Going into the Constitution Center main exhibit, I expected to see at least a section of the room that was very clearly dedicated to women’s history month, something that would stand out amongst everything else, to celebrate women’s achievements in history. I was disappointed when I found out that this “exhibit”, which was really just a few small pieces of women’s history, were scattered throughout the main exhibit and I really had to search for them. They did not stand out as I had hoped. There were only four aspects of Women’s history that were on display. These included the following: some information about a few women in their virtual touch screen “American National Tree”, a letter by Susan B. Anthony and a few items from the women’s suffrage movement, Sandra Day O’Connor’s Supreme Court robe and an equal rights amendment button from the 1970s. Although I did find these items interesting, I wanted so much more. I understand that the Constitution Center was presenting women’s events that were relevant to the Constitution, but I still expected a more elaborate exhibit at least for this celebratory month.

The Nineteenth Amendment and women’s suffrage were the two most prominent aspects of women’s history that the exhibit focused on, but this focus was very broad and it left out some other very important changes that came along with suffrage and voting.   In Reva B. Siegel’s article “She the People: The Nineteenth Amendment, Sex Equality, Federalism, and the Family,” she mentions that the passing of the Nineteenth Amendment not only gained women the right to vote, but that “in the immediate aftermath of ratification, both the Supreme Court and Congress understood the Nineteenth Amendment to redefine citizenship for women in ways that broke with the marital status traditions of the common law” (1018). This right went against everything that a “true woman” should be, and now America’s “new woman”, with her extravagant hats and comfortable pants, was able to participate in the voting process, one of the most important parts of American society, without the need of man. These are among many of the very important changes that women went through in the process of gaining the right to vote, and sadly, they are not really mentioned in the exhibit.

The Constitution Center offers other Women’s History Month events, including a lecture and an interactive show that have gotten great reviews and I am sure they are wonderful, but I chose to go to the general exhibit and to do the “Women’s History Self-Guided Tour” because I wanted to see how or if they changed the main exhibit to integrate some kind of special tribute to women’s history. What I found did not feel special, and I walked away from this experience thinking about how much women’s history is really available to the public. The information that is available to the general public about the history of women is so selective and I feel that if I hadn’t learned so much about women’s history in college, I would never have the knowledge that I do now, without having to do my own research. The most pleasing aspect of my trip was the area of the gift shop that had an entire revolving rack of children’s books dedicated to women, which I found very amusing and totally unexpected due to the limited amount of information on women in the exhibit. There were several coloring books dedicated to famous American women and the first ladies. There was also a paper doll book called “Fashions of the First Ladies Paper Dolls”. These coloring books are just about the only kind of women’s souvenir you could buy, besides a few Betsy Ross items and although they were coloring books which were very clearly made for little girls, they made me feel a little bit more hopeful, and a little bit jealous that I never had one growing up.

Works Cited

Siegel, Reva B. “She the People: The Nineteenth Amendment, Sex Equality, Federalism, and the Family”. Harvard Law Review 115.4 (2002): 947–1046. JSTOR. Web.

National Constitution Center’s Women’s History Inclusion by Lisa Bugasch

 

NCCTo make the most out of Women’s History Month, I went to the National Constitution Center to view their exhibits and see how they incorporated women’s history into the Constitutional history of the United States. I had not been to this site for many years – not since I was a child- and my nostalgia for the history showed here made me expect magic and inspire national pride in me. I expected to learn about the founding of our nation and here about the key players that shaped the United States into what it is today. My childlike wonder may have caused me to be naïve, but I truly was expecting more women included in the main exhibits, especially since the museum boasted about its female history in a pamphlet about Women’s History Month. The National Constitution Center is lacking in the incorporation of female contributions to the development of this nation.

I visited the Richard and Helen DeVos Exhibition Hall, which is a chronology of the making of the United States. While I commend this exhibit for its interactivity, I am concerned about its lack of female contributions. The center had a pamphlet detailing the “Must-see highlights” in their exhibit to celebrate Women’s History Month. The seven highlights included shout outs to t, and a surprisingly inclusive American National Tree offering biographies of influential American citizens. The fact that there are only seven highlights that they chose from the entire museum is troubling. The NCC’s mission statement reads that “the Constitution Center brings the United States Constitution to life by hosting interactive exhibits and constitutional conversations and inspires active citizenship by celebrating the American constitutional tradition,” (National Constitution Center). The main exhibit shows a startling lack of female contribution to the United States Constitution history. Along with the women that they did mention, they could have included Florence Kelley and the National Consumers’ League, the implications of Roe v. Wade, and more women of color just to name a few. Asserting that their exhibits show “celebrate the American constitutional tradition,” while barely showing female contributions diminishes and belittles the contributions that they did make.

With all of their faults, the NCC’s American National Tree exhibit does merit some celebration. This exhibit allowed patrons to learn about over influential citizens through biographies. It showed the history of many women as well as men. This exhibit even seemed to have just as many women as there were men. I was impressed by this contribution, and I wished that they would have done more of this throughout the museum.

The National Constitution Center has the potential to become an effective representation of the importance of constitutional history. In order to do this, they must include more information about women. They should focus more on movements, events, and collective accomplishments rather than the lives of individual women. This shows the female’s greater contributions to society today, (Alice-Kessler Harris and Sonya Michel). They cannot erase the importance of women from constitutional history. By doing this, they risk the alienation from an entire gender. When young women enter this institution they deserve to see their faces represented in the exhibits. Inspiring active citizenship among one gender inspires a lack of self-efficacy in the other.

 

References

“About the Constitution Center,” Constitutioncenter.org  http://constitutioncenter.org/about

“How to Build a Women’s History Museum,” Alice Kessler Harris and Sonya Michel.  History

News Network, 2014. http://historynewsnetwork.org/article/157004