In “The Construction of Impossibility: A Logic-Based Analysis of Conjuring Tricks,” Smith, Dignum, and Sonenberg (2016) examine how magic creates the experience of witnessing something impossible. They argue that this experience depends on the whole sequence of a performance, rather than a single moment of distraction. Their account distinguishes the sequence spectators believe they have witnessed from the actual sequence that makes the trick work. Apparent impossibility emerges when the final outcome conflicts with expectations formed from earlier events, yet spectators cannot resolve that conflict. The authors illustrate their framework through a logical analysis of a close-up trick. This is a theoretical account of how magic is constructed, rather than an experiment measuring audience responses.
This distinction helps me connect the creative and empirical directions of my project. In my narrative game, an agent predicts a participant’s choice through concealed eye-tracking. I need to consider what participants believe the system can observe at each stage, because a correct prediction alone may not create a magical experience. For the artwork, the gap between the visible encounter and its hidden operation invites reflection on our dependence on technologies we only partly understand. For the study, it helps distinguish participants’ observations from their explanations. I will collect both, alongside their confidence, perceived impossibility, and recognized knowledge gaps. LLMs will then interpret these accounts with or without the additional self-reports. The article supports my decision to treat perceived impossibility separately from confidence: someone might find the outcome difficult to explain while remaining confident in a particular explanation. It also gives me a way to review whether the narrative prepares the reveal clearly.
This week, I finalized the current empirical study design in preparation for meeting with my committee members on Thursday. The meeting has not happened yet, so I do not have feedback to report. I would like to discuss whether the participant questions clearly distinguish observation, explanation, and awareness of missing knowledge, and whether the planned comparisons can answer my research questions.
For my proof of concept, I am developing the narrative arc, the guide character, and the overall visual presentation. I plan to create a short playable sequence that takes a participant through the setup, private choice, and prediction reveal. I already have an eye-tracking prediction demo; the next step is to give that mechanism a coherent experience around it. This proof of concept will help me assess the pacing, clarity of instructions, and relationship between the character’s behavior and the reveal before expanding the full website.
Reference
Smith, W., Dignum, F., & Sonenberg, L. (2016). The construction of impossibility: A logic-based analysis of conjuring tricks. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, Article 748. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00748