How to Read a Book

The “typical” history book is made up of the following major pieces:

  • Front matter
    • Publication and citation information
    • Acknowledgements
    • Introduction or Prologue
  • Body (Chapters)
  • Back matter
    • Conclusion or Epilogue
    • Notes
    • Bibliography

Begin with a brief search of the author. Do they have a faculty profile (most of the time, yes)? Perhaps their CV is linked there–what do they study? What is their thematic constellation? Perhaps you can get some idea of what their academic goals and intended interventions are.

Look through the front matter and read the acknowledgements (yes, acknowledgements will sometimes be in the back. Whatever). Authors will, occasionally, state their research question in the acknowledgements. For older works, authors’ and editors’ prefaces can be extremely illuminating as you search for the book’s research question, its impact on historiography, its limitations, etc.

Closely read the introduction. For books with prologues, it’s helpful to think “I wish this was a straightforward introduction and not a heady prologue given that I am overwhelmed and would much prefer that the author simply tell me what they’re going to say.” Anyway, typical history book introductions will include the following elements:

  • Topic and scope. This is the “5Ws,” if you will: who, what, when, where, and why. Who does the book study? Do the people make up a group or institution? Where are they from? What language do they speak? Are they the focus because of their impact or because of the records they left behind? Are we learning about them from their own voices or are they the subject of other records produced by another person or institution? What is the author’s frame of analysis or, in other words, since history books show change over time, what is changing over time? Over what span does the change happen? Why is this important or, in other words, what is the author’s goal in writing the book?
  • Thesis and arguments. This will be the answer(s) to the author’s research question(s). The core thesis is often helpfully stated in some form of “this book argues ___,” and what other threads or supporting arguments is the author putting forth?
  • Organization. Sometimes the book’s organization will be absent from the introduction and you can rely on the table of contents and chapter titles to get a feel for organization, but I find it helpful to map out the chapter structure so that I can reference them before beginning each new chapter. The themes that the author intends to highlight such as race, gender, economics, class, agency, etc. are often stated in the introduction.
  • Methods. Ah yes, methods. You can, hopefully, get a feel for how the author is engaging with their body of primary sources and the historiography through the introduction. Microhistory? Global history? Is the book a work of political, social, cultural, economic history, is it cross-disciplinary? The possibilities are endless.
  • Historiography. The author may or may not explicitly state their historiographical intervention. Are there two opposed schools of thought in this field? Is the author taking a side or trying to find common ground? Is the author trying to open a new line of inquiry?

At this point, you should have an idea of what the author is trying to argue and how they intend to support their arguments. Now, move onto the conclusion and roughly repeat the process of identifying the above items. You may or may not find entirely new information here, but a concrete understanding of the intro and conclusion is integral to understanding the book. From here, move forward to the notes and bibliography.* What are the author’s bodies of primary sources? Our very own Dr. Lockenour, for example, wrote some highly acclaimed pieces using films as primary sources. Do any sources stand out as unusual? Speaking to myself here, try not to overthink these questions. I find it helpful to consider what I think I would use if, now that I just read the intro and conclusion, I had to conduct research to support the thesis. For example, if the book argues that Jimmy, Sally, and Tilly’s influence on civic planning in Pecanville led to a reduction in industrial pollution that later served as a model for Orchardtown and the City of Birch, then I might expect to find civic planning committee minutes, local newspapers, correspondence between the three protagonists and members of city councils elsewhere, zoning actions, etc. Whether the archival sources line up with my educated guess gives me an indication of whether I have a good understanding of where the book is headed or if, perhaps, I missed something in my assessment of the book’s method.

Assessing the bibliography is actually incredible simple: you just need to read every book. If time constraints don’t allow such a straightforward approach, one option is to give up right there. In all seriousness, you will naturally build your understanding as you continue to read. One useful assessment, should you have the time, is to take another look at the acknowledgements. What academics does the author acknowledge? Do these scholars appear in the bibliography? Briefly search a few of the scholars acknowledged as being particularly influential–what are their subfields or thematic interests? See if you can take that information and use it to look up abstracts or reviews for, let’s say, five books that seem significant out of the multitude present in the bibliography. With this slice of information, do you have an idea of what kinds of works the book’s author is reading? No? That’s ok. Be patient and it’ll click eventually.**

At this point, you may have spent 2-3 hours on everything on either side of the chapters themselves. I like to review my notes on the book’s arguments and structure before embarking on the first chapter, then it might be a good idea to go for a walk around the block or grab a snack. Otherwise, if you’re like me, it’ll be 7 PM before you realize that you haven’t eaten today, and this is suboptimal.

Carefully read the chapter’s introduction. This might be straightforward, as some books have clear section breaks after the chapter’s introductory paragraphs. If not, do your best to identify the introduction. After reading the introduction, read the first sentence of every paragraph and move on if it makes sense. If the author’s point in the first sentence does not make sense, continue reading until either you are convinced or you finish the paragraph and realize that you have not been convinced. What part of the argument is this paragraph supposed to support? Make note of the threads that you find tenuous–this will be useful as you consider your evaluation. Continue in this manner until you finish the chapter, then reference your notes on the chapter against your notes on the introduction and conclusion. Finally, take a lap around the block and, as needed, eat some dang food. Reiterate this process until you finish the book. Yay! Easy!

Review your notes and begin assessing the book. Your ability to assess, of course, will continue to grow as you continue to read books.

Finally–and this is a major pain in the butt that I continue to avoid–condense your notes and assessment in the form of a precis or other brief narrative. During my first semester, a professor remarked that you may end up with eight, nine, or even ten pages of notes on a book. I tend to go overboard with notes and will end up with twelve pages of notes before I’m halfway through the book (this is usually counterproductive and not sustainable given time constraints). Try and capture the highlights–what’s the thesis, is the evidence convincing, what are the primary inflection points highlighted by the author in their portrayal of change over time, etc.

*Some books have one or the other, and some have neither. Some books have numbered notes, some do that absolutely infuriating thing where the note is just the first few words in a sentence and then you have to match up the referenced sentence to the notes. I hate that. Anyway, in the interest of not judging a book by its cover, its notes, or its bibliography, don’t discount a book because the way it presents itself does not fall in line with the contemporary way we assess scholarly rigor.

**For reference, my first experience with this naturally clicking happened at the beginning of my third semester. I bet that you can beat that score.

Leave a comment