Iliadis and Ford’s 2023 article Fast Facts: From Personalization to Centralization is an examination of Google’s then-new practice of condensing information and facts about frequently searched terms and presenting them directly to users on the results page. This feature was the precursor to today’s “AI overviews” (which the article acknowledges as being in early stages of implementation), and at the time didn’t acknowledge which sources the search engine used as the basis for its answers. This made the answers Google provided appear as though they came from the platform itself, which the authors point to as evidence of a trend away from the personalization which marked the rise of many large platforms like Google and towards a trend of consolidating facts and information as a means of providing better value for consumers than their competitors (Iliadis & Ford, 2023). Additionally, they explore Google’s implementation of knowledge graphs as part of a larger push the company began in 2012 where they moved away from focusing on keyword matching to a logic more focused on semantic meaning. While this was nominally undertaken as a way of delivering to users the precise answers they were looking for, in practice it revealed how these companies were inadvertently constructing and defining the semantic meanings of terms users were searching for, as evidenced by contemporary Google searches for “cloud” returning results related to cloud computing, and “sky” gave results focused primarily on the British broadcasting network of the same name (Iliadis & Ford, 2023).
This article provides both a useful snapshot of how information is structured and displayed on the internet in the early to mid-2020’s, as well as pointing to the power wielded by those who create and manage those systems. While today’s “AI overviews” acknowledge the sources they’re pulling from so that it doesn’t appear as though the information is coming directly from Google, it has still resulted in web traffic in general cratering as people no longer feel the need to click through to the actual websites where the information resides. It feels like it’s the endpoint of the consolidation and monopolization of information Iliadis and Ford were warning about in their article just three years ago, where Google makes itself practically indispensable for finding things on the Internet, but extends that necessity beyond finding websites and into the realm of knowledge itself. The article references the phrase “computational ontology” to reference how Google is attempting to structure search results based on concept’s meaning and relations to each other, and I can already feel myself itching to use that in my own project (Iliadis & Ford, 2023).
Speaking of the project, I haven’t made as much progress on it this week, but I’m using this time to plan ahead for the next couple weeks to build out more of my research plan, start sharing my pre-production materials with my committee, and design my proof of concept. Now that I feel like I have enough material to build off of, I feel like I’m in a good place where I have things to revise instead of having to come up with everything from scratch. The writing workshop was also really helpful in forcing me to thread together where my research stands now, and gave me a good perspective on where to go next and what areas I should build out more. Below is my (bad) poem built from the free-writing exercise, plus my short description of the project, which feels like a more complete version than anything else I have so far but probably still needs work.
Equal parts exciting and intimidating
Juggle all the different parts
Everything feels like it’s down to me
I’ve never made something like this before
The kind of challenge that excites me
Make stuff that would make people think
My project is an interactive video which presents as a media artifact from the future. It’s a training module for the user’s first day at their new job with the Department of Hyperreality, a government body tasked with managing the mediated experiences of citizens living in the arcologies that many people now live in after a series of environmental catastrophes and the collapse of the Internet after it was overrun by AI agents. It’s a window into a world that has fully given itself over to the idea that what exists on the screen, digitally, or online is just as real as the things that exist in tangible, physical reality. Over time, it becomes clear that what this also means is that the larger society in these arcologies has fully given up on trying to repair the environment or even venture beyond the arcologies. Instead of rebuilding the world, they’ve rebuilt digital infrastructure. By the end of the project, it becomes clear that the hyperreality the Department has devoted itself to managing has resulted in a society where one can’t be fully sure of what is actually true beyond their moment to moment experience. The hope is that the user will walk away from my project ready to critically examine trends in our current media environment and what it means for technology companies to be pushing us towards a world where we can’t be sure if most of the images crossing our screens are “real” or not, and what it even means for us to call something “real” anymore.
Article Cited: Iliadis, A., & Ford, H. (2023). Fast facts: Platforms from personalization to centralization. Social Media + Society, 9(3), 20563051231195546. https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051231195546