Author: Amalia Inkeles

On September 24, the Temple Environmental Law Society hosted a panel discussion about careers in public interest law. The three panelists, Charlie McPhedran (Earthjustice), Lisa Palumbo (Legal Aid Chicago) and Kathryn Urbanowicz (Clean Air Council) discussed their paths to environmental law, both direct and circuitous.

Mr. McPhedran described his path from environmental science to environmental law, and his transition as an attorney from the EPA to Earthjustice. Ms. Palumbo’s path began in immigration law, eventually intersecting with environmental law through her work advocating for workers in the swine industry. Meanwhile, Ms. Urbanowicz described moving from environmental science to public defense before ultimately returning to environmental work as an attorney.

Together, the panelists’ careers illustrated the breadth of environmental law. They described various types of environmental law work they’ve encountered, from government regulation to community-driven litigation. The panelists also emphasized invaluable skills as a public interest advocate. Mr. McPhedran pointed out that trial advocacy is an important skill environmental attorneys rarely have, so it’s one worth cultivating. Ms. Urbanowicz also highlighted the importance of flexibility as an environmental attorney. “Lawyers are uniquely situated for critical thinking and discernment,” she said, explaining how these skills allow attorneys to move between different areas and find where they can be most useful. This view was shared by Ms. Palumbo, who described how her experience advocating in deportation hearings translated to litigating exposure cases for farm laborers and meatpackers.

A student asked the panelists how they maintain positivity in the face of adversity. Ms. Palumbo emphasized the need to absorb the difficulties of public interest work while also holding on to the small victories. The other panelists agreed, as most cases won’t be precedent-setting victories. Nor does every venue offer good prospects, Mr. McPhedran admitted, but attorneys can improve their chances by choosing venues wisely and researching judges. Ms. Urbanowicz shared how she sustains her work with radical acceptance. “I don’t strive for positivity,” she said. “I strive for strength.”